Haunted Northeast Florida: 6 Ghost Stories Locals Still Talk About
Sure, Northeast Florida is all sunshine and beach days — but when the sun goes down? The history gets a little darker… and way more interesting.
From haunted inns to colonial cemeteries, the First Coast is crawling with stories of lingering spirits and unexplained encounters. Whether you’re a true believer or just in it for the chills, these ghostly tales are part of what makes Northeast Florida’s past so fascinating.
So light a candle, charge your phone flashlight, and let’s explore the creepiest corners of the coast.
🪦 1. The Ghost Bride of Casa Marina Hotel (Jacksonville Beach)
Locals say a young bride died on her wedding night here in the 1920s — and never left. Staff have reported cold spots, flickering lights, and the soft rustle of a dress when no one’s around.
Bonus: You can still stay at the hotel and test it out for yourself (if you dare).
🕯 2. Old Jail Museum (St. Augustine)
You can feel the history here — and the heavy energy. Built in 1891, this former jail saw executions, riots, and plenty of ghost stories. Today, it’s one of St. Augustine’s top haunted sites, complete with night tours.
Pro tip: Go on a small-group tour so you can linger where the EMF meters start going wild.
🌕 3. The Lighthouse Keeper at St. Augustine Lighthouse
Several deaths occurred during the construction of this iconic lighthouse, including a group of children. Guests report hearing footsteps, giggles, and even seeing shadowy figures move up the spiral stairs.
Bring your camera — ghost hunters say it’s a hotspot for full-body apparitions.
🔥 4. Kingsley Plantation Spirits (Fort George Island)
This historic plantation site is rich in both history and heavy energy. Some visitors report hearing voices near the slave quarters or seeing movement in the corner of their eye along the tree-shrouded walking path.
Whether or not you believe in ghosts, it’s a powerful and emotional place.
💀 5. Tolomato Cemetery (St. Augustine)
One of the oldest cemeteries in Florida — and one of the most mysterious. People claim to see ghostly monks, hear soft chanting, or feel a rush of cold air even on the hottest days.
It’s closed to walk-ins, but you can view it from outside the gate (and snap photos through the iron bars — if you’re brave enough).
🛏️ 6. Amelia Island’s Florida House Inn
Built in 1857, this Fernandina Beach landmark has hosted presidents, pirates, and allegedly… a woman named Lola. Guests report hearing her footsteps at night, or even seeing her pacing near the upstairs windows.
Stay for the history. Stay up late for the haunts.
🎃 Looking for Something Fun (and Freaky) to Do?
There are tons of ghost tours across Jacksonville, Amelia Island, and St. Augustine — whether you want something light and fun or seriously spine-tingling.
📬 Want My List of Favorite Local Ghost Tours?
I’ve got a round-up of the best locally run tours — no cheesy tourist traps, just real stories, historic spots, and goosebump-worthy experiences.
Ready to get some spooky tours? Just DM me “spooky”
