Where to Find Shark Teeth in Amelia Island: A Local’s Guide
If you’ve ever strolled the sandy shores of Amelia Island and caught someone crouched low, squinting at the ground like they just lost a diamond ring — chances are, they were on the hunt for shark teeth. And honestly? They might have found one.
Amelia Island is one of Northeast Florida’s best-kept secrets for fossil lovers and beachcombers alike. Whether you’re new to the search or just want to know where the pros go, this quick guide will have you sifting like a local in no time.
🏝 Why Amelia Island is a Shark Tooth Hotspot
Shark teeth wash up all along the East Coast, but Amelia Island’s unique coastal currents, shallow shelf, and ancient fossil beds make it a prime location. Bonus? The beaches are beautiful even if you don’t strike prehistoric gold.
📍 Best Places to Hunt for Shark Teeth
Here are three tried-and-true local spots to explore:
1. Main Beach
A favorite for locals and visitors alike. Start early in the morning or just after high tide when new shells and treasures have been stirred up.
2. Peter’s Point Beachfront Park
Plenty of parking, restrooms, and a long, less crowded stretch of sand. Bring a sifter and hit the tide line.
3. North Beach (Ft. Clinch Area)
This area tends to be rockier and a bit wilder — exactly where ancient teeth love to hide.
⏰ Pro Tips for Maximum Finds
Timing is Everything: Head out just after high tide or after a storm when the surf churns up fresh layers of sand.
Tools Help: A basic sand sifter or colander-style scoop will save your back and help you scan more quickly.
Look for Contrast: Shark teeth are typically black, dark brown, or gray — look for triangle shapes that stand out against white shells.
🦷 What Are You Finding?
Most shark teeth found on Amelia Island are from species like lemon sharks, sand tigers, and bull sharks — and some can be thousands of years old. Some beachcombers have even stumbled upon megalodon teeth (yep, the real sea monster).
🍦 Bonus: Cool Off After the Hunt
Found your fossil or just enjoyed the walk? Treat yourself! Grab a scoop at DeNucci’s Soft Serve or sip something refreshing at Amelia Island Coffee in downtown Fernandina Beach.
📬 Want More Hidden Beach Tips?
I’ve got a personal map of the best fossil spots, shell locations, and quiet beach access points — all from years of local exploring. Want me to send it to you?
👉 just hit reply and say “Beach Me!” — I’ve got you.
